hey
i am trying photoshop cs 6 and made a signature
with text:
[you must login to view images]
without text:
[you must login to view images]
plz give some feedback i like to improve my work

Pretty good.
The text could be better
The effects are really cooler though!
I rate it 8/10 :)

thanks yea i suck at text thats why i always hava a copy without i will add it to the thread

If it's a start to your siggy-career, it's a good start. As DarkMew said, the text could be better, but tbh, I just don't like the picture. The effects, again, as DarkMew said, are good.

Overall, I rate it a 6.5-7/10. There could be some improvements to it. :P

Nice, the text is a little blurry when you first look at it though

Thanks i am folowing tutorials for the text so i will try to improve the text for me new work

Eh to tell you the truth (i'm going to be blunt so no hard feelings here) it sucks.
There's no flow to this and the background is too mono and just feels like you pre-prepared a background to put a decent looking render on.

Try to improve by using renders which create flow by themselves; like spiderman punching or jumping, some kind of action that incites movement in your eyes just by looking at it. This kind of movement without moving will help you create a significant flow to the signature by following the character or flowing back from the focal point ie. a fist in a punching render would be a good place for the start of flow whilst it could end just past the render as you dont want to direct eyes to behind the focal.

A good focal point is always needed in any signature as without a good focal point the viewers eyes will just wander around the signature before finding the thing you wanted them to see first, which is not what you want as a sig maker. Good focal can be created through blurring out of unnecessary parts to the sig and sharpening of the focal point in order to make it stand out.

Colour scheme too is incredibly important and can make or break a good signature. A signature with just one colour used will be referred to as mono and is generally a thing you'd want to stay away from as mono signatures look, well, bland. Try to incorporate 2-3 main colours from your render or stock in the finished signature so that it sticks from being mono and everything blend well together at the end.

Blending is another concern as bad blending can mean things look slapped onto a background, as yours does. Alternatively good blending can help merge all elements of the signature together in order to create a harmony between the things you're putting together on canvas.

Now i've typed way too much and far more than you'll need at a beginners level but i thought i should introduce the concepts and things that you will have to think about in order to improve at making signatures.

Have fun if you decide to continue and don't let my huge walls of text put you off!

This message is hidden because this person has been banned.

Ok thanks a lot for the tips i will improve my work and at the moment i am following tutorials for improving

I like the right half, but for the other side if you wanna keep it indeed of maybe cropping, possibly try maybe a different font with some texture, maybe even bring out some of the reds and whites into the letter, it just needs some more balance is all :) you are almost there!!!

Awesome siggy like said before little blurry but over all cool :) good job